Method Recovery Priority Index

Description

Rates lost and cross-domain methods on evidence base, recovery feasibility and expected impact (1-5 stars) to assign HIGH or MEDIUM revival priority.

The treatise's appendix rates candidate methods on three dimensions: Current Evidence Base (how much validated research supports the method), Recovery Feasibility (how practical it is to revive in contemporary contexts) and Expected Impact (the improvement in UX outcomes widespread recovery would bring), each scored one to five stars, with an overall priority of HIGH or MEDIUM. For example, Wizard of Oz scores 4/5/5 (HIGH), Braun and Clarke thematic analysis 5/5/5 (HIGH), and CWA and STAMP/STPA 5/2/5 (MEDIUM because feasibility is low). The index makes recovery investment explicit and comparable, and can be applied by any team to its own candidate methods with local feasibility judgements.

Attributes

Loss type
Community-proposed
Stage
Strategy
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. List candidate methods for recovery or adoption.
  2. Rate evidence base from the literature (1-5).
  3. Rate recovery feasibility given skills, tools, time and organisational context (1-5).
  4. Rate expected impact on decisions and user outcomes (1-5).
  5. Assign priority (for example HIGH when impact and evidence are high and feasibility is at least 3).
  6. Plan recovery for HIGH methods and revisit ratings annually.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Drummond MF et al. (2015) Methods for the Economic Evaluation of Health Care Programmes (priority-setting analogue)

Also known as

  • MRPI
  • Lost method prioritisation index

Categories

  • Community-Proposed Frameworks