Mental Model Elicitation (Expected IA)

Description

Short contextual interviews asking where users expect to find a function and why, sketched as an 'expected IA' and compared with the real IA to predict misroutes.

Mental models are users' internal guesses of where something should be; when they do not match the information architecture, users wander, backtrack or give up. In the forward-thinking playbook the method is deliberately light: 4–8 quick contextual interviews with a prompt such as 'If you wanted to set a price alert, where would you look first? Why?', simple diagrams of each participant's expected IA, and a comparison with the actual IA. In the worked example 5 of 8 participants said alerts should be under Markets while the app placed them under Notifications, a mismatch that predicts confusion before any tree test. Verbatims and sketches are compiled in one worksheet and coded with short low-granularity labels such as 'Alerts under Markets' or 'Notifications = OS updates'. Combined with CPM-GOMS, it yields a falsifiable hypothesis about why and where time will spike.

Attributes

Loss type
Active
Stage
Discovery, Design
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Choose the target functions whose location is in question.
  2. Run 4–8 quick contextual interviews asking where participants would look first and why.
  3. Sketch each participant's expected IA as a simple diagram.
  4. Compile verbatims and sketches into one worksheet (participant, exact quote, expected IA, initial hunch).
  5. Code utterances with short labels and count agreement (e.g. 5/8 expect Alerts under Markets).
  6. Compare expected and actual IA and write a falsifiable misroute hypothesis for tree testing.

Sources

  • Vivek Gopinath (2025), Forward-Thinking UX Research Playbook: A Mixed-Methods, Decision-Ready Approach from Prediction to Validation
  • Mental Models
  • Cognitive Psychology
  • Mental Models: Aligning Design Strategy with Human Behavior (Indi Young)
  • The Design of Everyday Things (Don Norman)
  • Mental Models (Indi Young)
  • Practical Empathy (Indi Young)

Also known as

  • Expected-IA interviews
  • Where would you look first?
  • Mental Models Research
  • Mental model mapping
  • Mental model diagramming
  • Mental Model Elicitation
  • Mental model diagram
  • Indi Young mental models
  • Alignment diagram of thinking

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation