Marr's Three Levels Applied to a Socio-Technical Task

Description

Describe what a work system computes independent of representation, then the representations and algorithms one tradition uses, then their physical implementation, contrasting traditions to expose hidden assumptions.

Marr argued that an information-processing system must be understood at three levels: the computational theory of what is computed and why, the representation and algorithm that carry it out, and the physical implementation. Hutchins applies this to a ship's navigation team. The computational level states the mapping between kinds of information and the constraints it satisfies, free of any tradition's representational assumptions. He contrasts Western chart-based fixing, where lines of position intersect on a chart, with Micronesian etak navigation, where the canoe is held fixed and a reference island moves under the star bearings, to show the same computation resting on radically different representations. Levels nest: what is implementation for the whole system becomes the computational task for the practitioners, so tools set the constraints of people's work. For UX this separates the job from today's tools before redesigning them.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. State the computational problem the work system solves and its constraints, without representational assumptions.
  2. Keep illustrations sparse and label which level each example belongs to.
  3. Find at least two traditions, tools or cultures that solve the same problem with different representations.
  4. Describe the representation and algorithm used by the tradition under study.
  5. Describe its implementation in tools, media and people.
  6. Note where the system's implementation becomes the practitioners' computational task, and identify which constraints a redesign could remove.

Sources

  • Cognition in the Wild (Hutchins, 1995)

Also known as

  • Computational account of a work task
  • Marr-level analysis of team work
  • Computational, representational and implementation analysis

Categories

  • User Research
  • Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling