Lincoln and Guba Trustworthiness Criteria

Description

Replaces positivist validity and reliability with credibility, transferability, dependability and confirmability, each secured by specific techniques such as member checking and audit trails.

Lincoln and Guba argued that qualitative research should not be judged by quantitative criteria but has its own parallel standards. Credibility (parallel to internal validity) is supported by prolonged engagement, triangulation, peer debriefing, negative case analysis and member checking. Transferability (external validity) is supported by thick description that lets readers judge applicability to their context. Dependability (reliability) and confirmability (objectivity) are supported by an audit trail documenting raw data, analytic decisions and reflexive notes, which an external auditor could follow. The framework turns 'qualitative is subjective' into a set of checkable practices. Its rigour comes from planning these techniques into the design rather than asserting trustworthiness afterwards.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Plan trustworthiness techniques at the design stage, mapping each of the four criteria to at least one concrete technique and recording the plan in the research protocol.
  2. Secure credibility through triangulation of sources or methods, peer debriefing with a researcher outside the project, and member checking of key interpretations with a subset of participants.
  3. Search actively for negative cases and revise interpretations until they account for disconfirming evidence or the exceptions are explicitly explained.
  4. Write thick description of participants, setting and context so readers can judge transferability to their own product or population.
  5. Maintain an audit trail of raw data, codebooks, memos, decision logs and reflexive notes throughout the study, not reconstructed afterwards.
  6. Report which techniques were used for each criterion, what they changed, and remaining limitations, in a dedicated methods or trustworthiness section.

Sources

  • Naturalistic Inquiry (Lincoln & Guba)
  • The Inquiry Series, Vol II, Ch 27
  • Gratton, C. & Jones, I., Research Methods for Sports Studies (2010)

Also known as

  • Trustworthiness criteria
  • Credibility, transferability, dependability, confirmability

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor