Description
Describe the same behaviour at several levels, from clicks to tasks to goals to the organisation, and look for patterns that only appear at one level.
In the Ant Fugue, Aunt Hillary is an ant colony that holds conversations although no single ant knows anything; the meaning exists only at the level of the whole colony. Hofstadter's point is that a system can be described at several levels, each with its own regularities, and that explanations often fail because they look at the wrong level. UX data is usually analysed at one level: click paths, or tasks, or goals. This method writes up the same set of observations at four or five levels in parallel and compares them. Problems that look like noise at the click level can be obvious at the goal level, such as people repeating a task because their real goal spans several sessions, and organisational patterns can explain individual behaviour that interviews treat as personal preference.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Systems & Complexity
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Discovery, Post-launch
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Pick a behaviour to explain and gather the data you have on it: logs, observation, interviews.
- Define the levels you will use, for example action (clicks and keystrokes), task, goal, role or team, and organisation or market.
- Describe the behaviour at each level separately, using only evidence that belongs to that level.
- Note the regularities that appear at each level and check whether they are visible from the levels above and below.
- Mark patterns that appear at one level only; these are usually where explanations have been going wrong.
- Write the explanation at the level where the pattern lives, and design the intervention for that level.
Sources
- Hofstadter, D., Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid (1979)
Also known as
- Multi-level behaviour analysis
- Aunt Hillary analysis
Categories
- Strategy & Collaboration
- Systems & Complexity