Description
Test each social rule a system enforces in code for fairness to the parties and benefit to the community, by modelling permissions as actor-entity-operation rights against explicit legitimacy principles.
Whitworth argues that online, code acts as law, and physical laws do not transfer, keep pace or have jurisdiction, so designers must re-derive what is legitimate for each application, as a jury applies the spirit of a law. Legitimacy is fairness (consequences match contributions) plus public good. The analysis models a social system as entities (personas, groups, agents, items, spaces, rights) and operations (null such as view, use, communication, social), allocates every non-null right to an accountable actor, and works through creation, display, delegation and re-allocation to decide whose consent each act needs. The result is a set of 18 proposed axioms, such as self-ownership of personas, prior mutual consent for communication, creator ownership, transparency of creation conditions and mutual consent for display. The audit form applies them hands-on to live systems: unfriending, banning, deleting posts, withdrawing uploads.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Systems & Complexity
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Definition, Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- List the social acts the system supports (post, delete, copy, join, ban, view, message, display).
- Inventory entities (personas, items, spaces, groups) and, for each role (owner, parent, ancestors, offspring, local public), write rights as actor-entity-operation triplets.
- Exercise the live system: create, use, edit and delete a persona and items, and record what can and cannot be changed and what remains.
- Test notification and consent: are unfriended, banned or removed people told; are creation conditions visible before creating?
- For each act ask whether the coded rule is fair to every party (consequences match contributions) and serves the community.
- Check findings against the 18 legitimacy principles and record violations.
- Propose rule changes as design requirements and check them for mutual consistency.
Sources
- HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)
- The Social Design (Whitworth & Ahmad, 2014)
Also known as
- Legitimacy analysis
- Legitimacy analysis and rights-based socio-technical specification
- Legitimacy review
- Legitimate by design
- Legitimate access control rights audit
- Online rights audit
- Socio-technical access control principles
- AEO rights analysis
- Social requirements analysis
Categories
- Strategy & Collaboration
- Systems & Complexity