Legitimacy analysis and access-rights audit

Description

Test each social rule a system enforces in code for fairness to the parties and benefit to the community, by modelling permissions as actor-entity-operation rights against explicit legitimacy principles.

Whitworth argues that online, code acts as law, and physical laws do not transfer, keep pace or have jurisdiction, so designers must re-derive what is legitimate for each application, as a jury applies the spirit of a law. Legitimacy is fairness (consequences match contributions) plus public good. The analysis models a social system as entities (personas, groups, agents, items, spaces, rights) and operations (null such as view, use, communication, social), allocates every non-null right to an accountable actor, and works through creation, display, delegation and re-allocation to decide whose consent each act needs. The result is a set of 18 proposed axioms, such as self-ownership of personas, prior mutual consent for communication, creator ownership, transparency of creation conditions and mutual consent for display. The audit form applies them hands-on to live systems: unfriending, banning, deleting posts, withdrawing uploads.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. List the social acts the system supports (post, delete, copy, join, ban, view, message, display).
  2. Inventory entities (personas, items, spaces, groups) and, for each role (owner, parent, ancestors, offspring, local public), write rights as actor-entity-operation triplets.
  3. Exercise the live system: create, use, edit and delete a persona and items, and record what can and cannot be changed and what remains.
  4. Test notification and consent: are unfriended, banned or removed people told; are creation conditions visible before creating?
  5. For each act ask whether the coded rule is fair to every party (consequences match contributions) and serves the community.
  6. Check findings against the 18 legitimacy principles and record violations.
  7. Propose rule changes as design requirements and check them for mutual consistency.

Sources

  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)
  • The Social Design (Whitworth & Ahmad, 2014)

Also known as

  • Legitimacy analysis
  • Legitimacy analysis and rights-based socio-technical specification
  • Legitimacy review
  • Legitimate by design
  • Legitimate access control rights audit
  • Online rights audit
  • Socio-technical access control principles
  • AEO rights analysis
  • Social requirements analysis

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Systems & Complexity