Learning Gap Analysis

Description

Describe the current and preferred states of a task, then classify each gap as knowledge, skill, motivation, environment or communication so the right kind of design response follows.

Gap analysis asks why people are not doing what a design expects, and refuses to assume the answer is more instruction. The team frames the current state with questions such as what goes wrong when people cannot do the task and how you would know. It defines the preferred state using Bloom's revised taxonomy for the level of mastery and a proficiency scale for how well people must perform. Each gap between the two is then classified by Dirksen's types: knowledge, skill, motivation, environment or communication. The type points to the response: an environment gap calls for changing the setting, not training; a skill gap needs practice, not information. The classified gaps then brief ideation.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Definition
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Choose the task or behaviour and ask the current-state questions: what goes wrong, for whom, and how would you know.
  2. Define the preferred state, specifying the Bloom's level and proficiency people need to reach.
  3. List each gap between current and preferred states.
  4. Classify each gap as knowledge, skill, motivation, environment or communication.
  5. Match design responses to gap types (information, practice, incentive, environmental change, clearer messaging).
  6. Use the classified gaps as the brief for ideation.

Sources

  • Universal Methods of Design (Martin & Hanington, 2019)

Also known as

  • Gap analysis for learning experiences
  • Current-to-preferred state gap analysis
  • Dirksen gap analysis

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice