Layered Elaboration

Description

A paper prototyping technique in which participants build and change an interface on stacked transparencies, each layer holding one element, so ideas can be added without destroying earlier ones.

Layered elaboration uses sheets of transparency laid over each other so that designs can be built and revised in layers. In the TableTalk Poker project, each layer held one salient interface element: the table, players, cards, prompts or chat. Water-soluble markers and sticky notes let participants move, add and remove buttons, text and screens on the fly. The team made three rough variants, briefed participants on the basics of the game, and then simulated play with sticky notes while participants carried out tasks such as joining a game, raising a bet, checking, calling, folding and chatting, thinking aloud as they went. Researchers watched for gaps in the interaction and noted desired layout changes. Because paper reduced attachment to any one design, participants mixed and matched elements across variants and reached a consensus design heavily shaped by their ideas. The team used younger adults without online gaming experience as proxies, because prototyping with older adults had proved difficult in earlier work, and then moved to iterative usability testing with older adults.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Stage
Design
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Prepare a few rough design variants split into layers, one element per transparency.
  2. Brief participants on the domain so they understand the tasks.
  3. Ask participants to perform tasks on the layered prototype, simulating system responses with sticky notes, while thinking aloud.
  4. Invite participants to move, redraw, add or remove elements on any layer.
  5. Repeat across variants and discuss as a group to converge on a preferred design.
  6. Photograph each state and carry the consensus design into higher-fidelity prototyping and testing.

Sources

  • Garcia-Ruiz, M. (ed.), Games User Research: A Case Study Approach (2016)

Also known as

  • Transparency-layer paper prototyping
  • Layered paper prototyping

Categories

  • Design
  • Participatory, Design & Futures