Description
Rate a work system against complementarity criteria at three levels, then run a facilitated participatory process to agree a design philosophy and derive human-automation requirements.
KOMPASS rejects allocating functions by comparing what humans and machines do best. Instead it asks whether people and automation complement each other so that humans keep control and meaningful work. Criteria sit at three levels: human-machine function allocation (process transparency, dynamic coupling, decision authority), the individual work task (task completeness, planning requirements, communication requirements, polyvalence) and the work system (collective autonomy). Trained analysts first rate existing systems against the criteria. A facilitated design team then agrees a shared design philosophy and evaluation concept, derives concrete requirements, and checks those requirements against the same criteria. The combination of explicit criteria and a participatory process is what distinguishes it from Fitts-list and levels-of-automation approaches.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Human Factors & Error
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Strategy, Definition, Design
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Months
Steps
- Assemble trained analysts and a cross-functional design team including operators.
- Rate the existing work system on each criterion at the three levels: human-machine allocation, individual task and work system.
- Feed the ratings back to the design team and facilitate agreement on a design philosophy for how people and automation should share work.
- Agree an evaluation concept stating how designs will be judged against the criteria.
- Derive concrete requirements for the automation and the tasks from the philosophy.
- Check each requirement against the criteria and revise until it supports transparency, decision authority and task completeness.
Sources
- Handbook of Cognitive Task Design (Hollnagel, 2003)
Also known as
- KOMPASS
- Complementary analysis and design
Categories
- Accessibility
- Human Factors & Error