Interpretive Repertoires and Ideological Dilemmas

Description

Identifies the culturally shared repertoires of terms and metaphors people draw on, and the contradictions (ideological dilemmas) they navigate when talking about a topic.

Interpretive repertoires (Wetherell & Potter) are culturally shared building blocks of conversation — recurrently used systems of terms, metaphors, and figures of speech that construct a particular version of an object, person, or action. Ideological dilemmas (Billig) are the contradictions within common-sense ideology that force people to navigate between competing cultural commitments. Together, these concepts reveal how people draw on available cultural resources (repertoires) to manage social life, and how they navigate the contradictions between them. Applied to UX: they reveal the competing cultural frameworks available to users for making sense of technology — and the tensions between them.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Identify interpretive repertoires: In your data, what recurrent systems of terms, metaphors, and phrases are used to construct versions of the phenomenon? Each repertoire is a coherent way of talking about something — and different repertoires construct it differently.
  2. Map repertoire distribution: Who uses which repertoires? In what contexts? Repertoire use is not random — it is strategically deployed to accomplish interactional purposes.
  3. Identify ideological dilemmas: Where do participants show inconsistency or tension between competing cultural commitments? ('I believe in privacy but I want personalisation.' 'I want simplicity but I need features.') These are ideological dilemmas.
  4. Dilemma navigation analysis: How do participants navigate the tension? What rhetorical moves do they use to manage the contradiction? What does the navigation reveal about their priorities and values?
  5. Application to design: Understanding the repertoires available to users for making sense of your product reveals what framings are available and which are absent — and which repertoire framings your product currently invokes.

Sources

  • Mapping the Language of Racism (Wetherell & Potter)
  • Ideological Dilemmas (Billig et al.)
  • Handbook of Discourse Analysis

Also known as

  • Interpretative repertoires
  • Ideological dilemmas analysis

Categories

  • Content
  • Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse