Interaction-type versus situational-factor reasoning

Description

List each device's input and output interaction types, relate situational factors to the interactions they impair, and subtract impaired channels to see which devices still serve a use case.

Devices are described by the interaction types of their widgets, such as touch, visual, audible, motion and location, split into inputs and outputs and optionally by information type (text, icons, maps, voice, alarm). A fixed relation links known situational factors, with value ranges where relevant, to the interactions they hinder: loud noise removes audio output, darkness or distance removes small text, vibration removes fine touch. When a situation occurs, the factors present at each device's location restrict the relation, the affected interactions are subtracted, and devices are classified as unusable, restricted or available and matched to the use case's needs. Originally used for medical devices taken into helicopters, it has been applied to repurposing public displays in emergencies. It can be implemented with ontologies and rules, though simple sets suffice.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Model each device's widgets by interaction type, split into inputs and outputs, and optionally by information type.
  2. Build the effects relation from all known situational factors, with value ranges, to the interaction types they impair.
  3. For a given situation, record the factors actually present at each device's location.
  4. Restrict the relation to those factors and subtract the affected interactions from each device.
  5. Classify devices as unusable, restricted or available and match remaining capabilities to the use case's information and input needs.
  6. Choose devices on a best-fit basis, or warn users how to adapt their use.

Sources

  • The Handbook of Formal Methods in HCI (Weyers et al., 2017)

Also known as

  • Context-of-use suitability reasoning
  • Context-of-use suitability modelling
  • Device interaction-effects relation
  • Bowen and Hinze situational reasoning

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error