Description
Analyses experiences as directed acts of consciousness, distinguishing how something is experienced (noesis) from what is experienced as meaningful (noema).
Phenomenology holds that consciousness is always consciousness of something: experiences are intentional, directed at objects. Husserl distinguished the noesis, the act of experiencing (perceiving, remembering, doubting, hoping), from the noema, the object as it is meant or experienced. Intentional analysis applies this to participants' accounts: for each experienced object, such as a claim form, a status screen or an approval message, it asks how the participant was relating to it (anticipating, fearing, checking, trusting) and what the object meant to them in that act. Two people looking at the same 'pending' screen may experience different noemata: a promise or a threat. For UX this exposes why identical interfaces produce different experiences. Rigour comes from systematically pairing acts and objects across meaning units and checking them against participants' language.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Goal
- Understand why
- Stage
- Discovery
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Collect detailed first-person descriptions of a specific episode of use, using prompts that elicit what the participant was attending to and how, from 6 to 15 participants.
- Divide each description into meaning units at shifts in meaning, and for each identify the object of attention.
- For each object, characterise the noetic act (seeing, anticipating, doubting, remembering, evaluating) and the noematic sense (what the object meant as experienced, for example 'a verdict', 'a receipt').
- Compare noetic-noematic pairs across participants for the same interface objects, noting where the same object is experienced in different modes.
- Relate patterns to participants' situations and histories that shape their intentional stance.
- Derive design implications for how objects should present themselves to support the intended mode of experience, and test with comprehension probes.
Sources
- Fundamentals of Qualitative Research
- Sage Handbook of Qualitative Data Collection (Flick)
- The Inquiry Series, Ch 30 — Phenomenological Methods — The Structure of Lived Experience
Also known as
- Noetic-noematic analysis
- Intentionality analysis
- Act-object analysis
Categories
- User Research
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis