Description
Walk scenarios of stakeholders, tasks and external events against system goals and specified outputs to discover obstacles, then add goals to maintain, avoid or repair those situations.
In the Inquiry Cycle, scenarios act as specific contexts for questioning a requirements specification. For each scenario of stakeholders, their tasks, external agents and events, analysts ask whether system output is relevant and acceptable to each stakeholder. Mismatches reveal obstacles: conditions, often caused by external agents or the environment, that could prevent a goal being achieved. Each obstacle prompts new or refined goals to maintain, avoid or repair the situation, and the specification is revised. Scenarios also supply input events for testing validation routines, and the cycle repeats. Van Lamsweerde and Letier formalised obstacle analysis in the KAOS goal-oriented method, checking goal achievability against environmental states drawn from scenarios. Sutcliffe recommends obstacle analysis as a requirements technique HCI could adopt; formal variants need detailed knowledge of the specification and environment.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Definition, Design
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Write the system goals and the current specification of outputs.
- Write scenarios covering stakeholders, their tasks, external agents and events, including unusual but plausible conditions.
- Walk each scenario against goals and specified outputs, asking whether each output is relevant and acceptable to each stakeholder.
- Record obstacles that could prevent goals, noting their cause (user, external agent, environment).
- Derive goals to maintain, avoid or repair each obstacle situation and revise the specification.
- Derive input events from scenarios as test data, and iterate the cycle until no new obstacles emerge.
Sources
- HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)
Also known as
- Inquiry Cycle: scenario-based obstacle analysis
- Inquiry-based requirements analysis
- ScenIC
- Obstacle analysis
Categories
- User Research
- Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling