Innovation Tracer Study

Description

Reconstruct, from interviews and records, the sequence of key events and decisions that produced an innovation, from the original need through research to launch.

A tracer study works backwards from a successful innovation to the events that produced it, using interviews with key participants, publications and archival records such as grants, patents and agency files. Project Hindsight traced 20 weapons systems; TRACES, Project Sappho and the Minnesota Innovation Project followed. Comroe traced about 500 key articles behind ten cardiopulmonary technologies and found 41 per cent were unrelated to the disease when published. Recurring findings: innovations need clusters of prior advances, often take around 19 years, and involve serendipity. Known weaknesses are that it is retrospective, studies only important successes, leans on publications so misses diffusion and consequences, and makes R&D look more rational than it was. In product organisations it can show how breakthrough features really emerged.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Strategy
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Choose the innovation and define its start and end points.
  2. Interview the key investigators, designers and decision-makers involved.
  3. Collect publications, design documents, grants, patents, tickets and other records.
  4. Order key events into a dated sequence, linking each to its evidence.
  5. Identify decisions, clusters of enabling advances and chance events, and note what the record cannot show (failures, abandoned paths).

Sources

  • Diffusion of Innovations (Rogers, 2003)

Also known as

  • Innovation history reconstruction
  • Project Hindsight method
  • TRACES study

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor