Information-access-cost manipulation

Description

Experimentally vary how costly it is to reach task information in the interface and measure how people trade off remembering, looking and acting.

Two paradigms show that people choose between memory and the world by milliseconds of cost. In Ballard's block-copying task, participants copy a pattern of coloured blocks while eye-tracked; they glance back at the model before and after each pick-up, storing only colour or position per glance, and miss changes made to the model while looking elsewhere. In Gray and Fu's task, people program a simulated VCR from show information that is either always visible or hidden under grey boxes needing a click. When access costs even a little, people switch to memory, preferring imperfect memory over perfect information in the world, which raises errors. The soft-constraints view treats these as cost-benefit trade-offs at the scale of a few hundred milliseconds. Clark frames the dispute with the minimal-memory view as evidence of a testable science of how cognition spreads across mind and interface.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Define a task that needs reference information (copying data between screens, entering details, comparing options).
  2. Make the information available at different access costs, for example always visible versus covered and click-to-reveal versus on another tab, with a group that memorised it beforehand.
  3. Record fixations, clicks, timing and errors; optionally change the reference covertly while the participant looks away to test what was retained.
  4. Compare strategy mix (look up versus recall), re-inspection counts, time and error rates across cost conditions.
  5. Interpret which resource people rely on at each phase and at what cost threshold they switch.
  6. Translate into design: keep needed information visible where errors are costly, or deliberately raise access cost only where memorisation is desired.

Sources

  • Supersizing the Mind (Clark, 2008)

Also known as

  • Information-access-cost manipulation and minimal-memory analysis
  • Gray-box paradigm
  • Soft constraints paradigm
  • Block-copying paradigm
  • Minimal memory strategy analysis

Categories

  • User Research
  • Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling