Description
After exposure to a regularity, ask people both to reproduce it and to avoid it; use above chance under exclusion shows knowledge outside voluntary control, judged against rigorous awareness tests.
Users often learn regularities in an interface (sequences, layouts, patterns) without being able to say so. Whether that knowledge is under voluntary control is tested with opposition logic: participants generate material once trying to reproduce what they saw (inclusion) and once trying to avoid it (exclusion). If trained chunks still appear above chance under exclusion, the knowledge influences behaviour against intention. Shanks adds two criteria for awareness tests: they must be exhaustive, sensitive to low-confidence hunches as well as confident knowledge, and they must probe the same information that drives behaviour. Verbal reports usually fail the first criterion; forced-choice recognition and asking for a fixed number of items are better. Many apparent demonstrations of unaware learning have dissolved once awareness was measured more sensitively.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Evaluation
- Data
- Quantitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Expose participants to material containing a regularity during an ordinary task and show learning with a performance measure, such as slower responses when the regularity is removed.
- Tell participants that a regularity existed.
- Inclusion: ask them to generate material that reproduces what they saw.
- Exclusion: ask them to generate material that avoids what they saw, including any part of it.
- Score generated material for trained chunks against chance; above-chance use under exclusion, or equal use under both instructions, indicates knowledge not under voluntary control.
- Add an objective awareness test of the same knowledge (forced-choice recognition of old versus new fragments) and an exhaustive subjective test (ask for a fixed number of items or hunches), and interpret dissociations only if both criteria are met.
Sources
- Handbook of Cognition (Lamberts & Goldstone, 2005)
Also known as
- Process-dissociation generation test
- Opposition logic test of intentional control
- Exhaustiveness and information criteria for awareness tests
- Subjective versus objective awareness tests
- Inclusion-exclusion generation test with awareness-test criteria
Categories
- User Research
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception