Importance-Performance Analysis

Description

Asks customers to rate how important each attribute of a service is and how well it performs, then plots the two scores on a grid to show where effort should go.

Importance-performance analysis is a survey-based evaluation technique. A list of service attributes is drawn up, and each respondent rates every attribute twice: once for how important it is to them and once for how well the provider currently performs on it. Mean scores are plotted on a two-dimensional grid with importance on one axis and performance on the other, and the grid is divided into four quadrants, usually at the overall means. Attributes that are important but performing poorly are the priority for action; important and well-performing ones should be maintained; unimportant but well-performing ones may be absorbing effort that could go elsewhere; and unimportant, poorly performing ones are low priority. Veal and Darcy list it alongside cost-benefit analysis and conjoint analysis as a formal technique for evaluating options, and note its closeness to the SERVQUAL approach, which compares expectations with performance. For UX teams it is a quick way to turn a satisfaction survey into a prioritised list of product attributes. Unlike regression-based key driver analysis, it uses stated importance rather than derived importance, so it is simple to explain but prone to everything being rated important.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify the attributes of the product or service to assess, from earlier interviews, focus groups, support data or the literature.
  2. Write paired items for each attribute: an importance rating and a performance (satisfaction) rating on the same scale.
  3. Survey a representative sample of current users and compute the mean importance and mean performance for each attribute.
  4. Plot each attribute on a grid with importance on one axis and performance on the other, and draw cross-hairs at the grand means or the scale midpoints.
  5. Read off the four quadrants: concentrate here, keep up the good work, low priority and possible overkill.
  6. Check the stability of the result by segment and, where possible, compare stated importance with importance derived from regression.
  7. Turn the 'concentrate here' quadrant into a ranked backlog and repeat the survey after changes to track movement.

Sources

  • Veal, A. J. & Darcy, S., Research Methods in Sport Studies and Sport Management (2014)
  • Feature Prioritization Methods (slide deck)

Also known as

  • IPA
  • Importance-performance technique
  • Importance-performance grid
  • Martilla and James quadrant analysis
  • IPA grid
  • Importance-satisfaction matrix
  • Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA)

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Survey & Psychometrics