Imagining Losing

Description

Imagine a rival launches a product that beats yours, write the story and artefacts of that loss, and identify the strategic weakness it exposes.

Rather than reacting to competitors' existing products, the team presumes a competitor launches something new and its own product loses badly. Team members picture both products side by side, imagine two target shoppers comparing them aloud and buying the rival, and write what they say and why they chose it: messaging, features, price, brand or packaging. They then make the rival concrete by sketching its differentiator (pricing, wireframes of key features, even an org chart), writing its launch press release and a mock magazine article on their own product's defeat. The final step names the weakness in the current strategy that allowed the loss. It works like a pre-mortem applied to competition.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Stage
Strategy
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Assume a competitor launches a new product and yours loses decisively.
  2. Imagine two target shoppers comparing the products aloud and write their conversation.
  3. Assume they buy the rival and list the reasons.
  4. Sketch the rival's differentiator: pricing, wireframes of features, organisation behind it.
  5. Write the rival's launch press release and a mock article about your product being overwhelmed.
  6. Identify the strategic weakness that let the rival win and turn it into defensive product priorities.

Sources

  • Well Designed (Kolko, 2014)

Also known as

  • Competitive loss scenario
  • Competitive pre-mortem

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice