Description
Explain why some cases are poor examples of a concept by stating the idealised model it presupposes, checking its fit, and splitting the concept into converging submodels and metonymic stand-ins.
Lakoff argues that words are defined against idealised cognitive models whose background assumptions do not fit the world perfectly. 'Bachelor' presupposes a society where men marry at a typical age, so the pope is a poor bachelor because the model does not apply, not because he partly belongs. 'Mother' is a cluster of birth, genetic, nurturance, marital and genealogical models; 'real mother' sentences, compounds such as stepmother and extended senses each pick out submodels. Metonymic models (stereotypes, typical examples, ideals, paragons, salient examples) let a subcategory stand for the whole and create further prototype effects, detectable with 'X, but Y' frames and inference asymmetries. Adapted for UX, the analysis explains why users mis-sort items, why a category label fails for edge cases, and which stereotype users reason from.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Discovery, Definition
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- State the idealised model the term or category presupposes, including its background assumptions.
- Test candidate cases for how well that background fits, separating poor fit from partial membership.
- Where people's weightings conflict with their definitions, model the surrounding ICMs whose logic explains the weights.
- If no single model covers all uses, list the converging submodels.
- Probe submodels with 'real X' sentences, compound modifiers and extended senses in interviews or corpora.
- Identify metonymic stand-ins (stereotype, typical case, ideal, paragon, salient example) and test them with 'X, but Y' contrast frames and inference asymmetries.
- Summarise the composite prototype and the deviations it explains, and relate them to labels and categories in the product.
Sources
- Women, Fire and Dangerous Things (Lakoff, 1987)
Also known as
- ICM analysis
- Background fit and cluster-model decomposition
- Cluster model analysis
- ICM fit analysis
- Metonymic model analysis
- Sources of prototype effects analysis
Categories
- Content
- Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse