Iconographic-Iconological Analysis (Panofsky) and Iconological Context Analysis

Description

Interpret images in three steps, from neutral description to conventional meanings to what they reveal about their culture, accounting for production and reception contexts.

Panofsky's method interprets images at three levels, each with its own object, required knowledge and corrective principle: pre-iconographical description of what is shown, iconographical analysis of conventional themes and motifs, and iconological interpretation of what the images reveal about the attitudes of their time and culture. Müller treats it as a qualitative, comparative and forensic method in which images are evidence for hypotheses about meaning in context. Her Iconological Context Analysis adds attention to visual form, six ideal-type production contexts (artistic, commercial, journalistic, scientific, political, private) and reception contexts, since an image made privately can take on new meaning when published. The method is inductive and holistic, needs cultural and historical knowledge, and is rooted in Western traditions, so interpretations must be referenced carefully to visual and textual sources.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Collect the visual material and pose a problem-oriented research question, refining it as you go.
  2. Classify visuals into your own types and tag every visual and textual source.
  3. Describe prototype images neutrally (pre-iconographical), attending to details and differences in form and style; compare descriptions.
  4. Iconographic analysis: bring visual and verbal sources together to attribute conventional meanings and form hypotheses.
  5. Analyse the production context (artistic, commercial, journalistic, scientific, political, private) and how it shapes form and intended meaning.
  6. Analyse reception contexts and what the images meant to their audiences.
  7. Iconological interpretation: state what the images convey about the social, political and cultural context.

Sources

  • The SAGE Handbook of Visual Research Methods (Margolis & Pauwels, 2011)

Also known as

  • Iconology
  • Iconography
  • Panofsky method
  • Iconological Context Analysis

Categories

  • Content
  • Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse