Iatrogenic UX Harm Analysis

Description

Examines harm caused by interventions meant to protect users (regulations, safeguards, policies), as with cookie consent banners producing near-universal uninformed consent.

In medicine, iatrogenic harm is caused by treatment. The treatise defines iatrogenic UX harm as design harm caused by an intervention (regulatory, organisational or technical) intended to protect users. Its canonical case is the cookie consent epidemic: GDPR's informed-consent requirement was implemented almost universally through banners that undermined informed consent via choice overload, asymmetric defaults and dark-pattern accept buttons. The regulation acted as a vector transmitting a new pathogen across the European-facing web at once, which then spread globally. Research finds 80-95% click 'Accept All' without reading; virtually no one makes a genuinely informed decision. Iatrogenic analysis evaluates protective interventions for their actual user outcomes, including second-order harms such as habituation and consent fatigue.

Attributes

Loss type
Community-proposed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Identify the protective intervention and its intended user outcome.
  2. Define measures of the intended outcome (for example informed consent) and possible harms (time, fatigue, habituation).
  3. Measure real-world implementation and behaviour across products.
  4. Compare outcomes with the intervention's goals and with alternatives.
  5. Identify design features driving harm (defaults, asymmetry, frequency).
  6. Recommend redesigned implementations or policy changes and evaluate them.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Utz C et al. (2019) (Un)informed consent: studying GDPR consent notices in the field. CCS
  • Nouwens M et al. (2020) Dark patterns after the GDPR. CHI
  • Illich I (1976) Limits to Medicine: Medical Nemesis

Also known as

  • Iatrogenic harm
  • Intervention-caused harm analysis

Categories

  • Community-Proposed Frameworks