i* goal and dependency modelling

Description

Diagram actors, hard goals, soft goals, tasks and resources with dependency and means-end links to reason about who depends on whom and how options affect quality goals.

The i* framework models organisations and systems as actors who depend on each other to achieve goals, perform tasks and supply resources. Hard goals become functional requirements; soft goals (usability, safety, cost, accuracy) become quality requirements judged by degree of satisfaction. A strategic dependency model maps actors and the dependencies between them; a strategic rationale model opens up each actor to show how tasks, sub-goals and resources serve its goals, and lets candidate system solutions be compared with arguments for and against, including their effects on soft goals. Goal hierarchies resemble hierarchical task models minus sequence, but i* also represents relationships between agents and organisational structures that task models lack. Sutcliffe notes that it offers little process guidance for agreeing requirements and that industrial effectiveness of formal requirements models is not demonstrated.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Identify actors: stakeholders, roles and systems, including automated agents.
  2. Record each actor's hard goals, soft goals, tasks and resources.
  3. Draw dependencies between actors for goals, tasks, resources and soft goals to form the strategic dependency model.
  4. Open each key actor into a strategic rationale model with means-end and decomposition links showing how tasks and resources achieve goals.
  5. Add candidate system solutions and mark their contributions (helps, hurts) to soft goals.
  6. Use the diagrams with stakeholders to discuss vulnerabilities, negotiate requirements and choose among alternatives.

Sources

  • HCI Encyclopedia (Soegaard & Dam, 2014)

Also known as

  • i-star
  • i* strategic dependency and goal modelling
  • Strategic dependency and strategic rationale models
  • Goal requirements notation (GRN)
  • Goal-oriented requirements engineering (GORE)

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Systems & Complexity