Human Factors Forensic Investigation

Description

Determines, for a specific injury or incident, whether the conditions a person faced exceeded normal human capability, by recreating the situation and comparing measurements with human factors data and standards.

Forensic human factors applies a basket of methods (observation, interview, reference data, problem solving and sometimes small experiments) to a legal question of fault: were the environmental and technological conditions within the injured person's threshold capabilities? Meister treats it as the sharpest real-world test of whether human factors data and methods hold up outside research, because the expert must make claims about a specific person in a specific situation rather than average performance. In his example of a fall on restaurant stairs, the investigator interviews the plaintiff and patrons, measures lighting levels, stair angle and carpet friction, compares them with standards, and tests whether people with normal vision can descend safely under the lighting conditions. The method's outputs must withstand cross-examination, so documentation of data, methods and assumptions is part of the procedure. In digital products, similar questions arise in disputes over dark patterns, consent flows and medical device use errors.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Post-launch
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Analyse the questions posed by the legal or incident situation to define the specific human factors questions.
  2. Recreate the performance situation, symbolically or physically, including the interface, environment and task as they were at the time.
  3. Determine the human factors data needed (for example visibility and lighting standards, reading time, response time, interface guidelines).
  4. Select methods to gather empirical data: measurement, observation, interviews, document review or a small experiment.
  5. Collect and analyse the data and judge whether the conditions exceeded normal human capability or departed from accepted standards.
  6. Document data, methods, assumptions and conclusions; brief counsel and testify if required.

Sources

  • Conceptual Foundations of Human Factors Measurement (Meister, 2004)

Also known as

  • HF expert witness investigation
  • Forensic human factors analysis
  • Forensic human factors

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error