Historical Research with External and Internal Source Criticism

Description

Reconstruct past events from primary and secondary sources, first testing each source's authenticity (external criticism) and then the credibility of its content (internal criticism).

Because the past cannot be observed, historical research tests the truthfulness of others' reports. Primary sources are either consciously transmitted (testimony, oral histories, letters, diaries, minutes, records, photographs, recordings) or unconsciously transmitted relics; secondary sources are accounts by non-witnesses and serve as supplementary witnesses. External criticism establishes genuineness: higher criticism tests authorship and date through anachronism checks, comparison with other evidence and physical analysis; lower or textual criticism reconstructs an original text from copies. Internal criticism then judges reliability using Travers's ten questions on the observer's competence, relation to events, pressure to distort, intent, expertise, habits, bias, delay before recording, memory and agreement with independent witnesses. Positive criticism seeks the real meaning; negative criticism seeks reasons to disbelieve. Records are incomplete and biased, and findings cannot be checked by experiment.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Identify and specify the historical question and any working hypotheses.
  2. Review existing accounts and collect primary and secondary sources (documents, tickets, specs, emails, recordings, oral histories).
  3. Apply external criticism: check authorship and date, look for anachronisms, compare with other evidence and examine version histories or metadata.
  4. Apply internal criticism using Travers's ten questions on each author's competence, position, pressures, intent, bias, delay, memory and corroboration.
  5. Apply both positive criticism (establish the intended meaning) and negative criticism (seek reasons to disbelieve).
  6. Drop sources that are inauthentic or irrelevant and weight the rest by credibility.
  7. Write the account, citing the source and its assessed credibility for each key claim.

Sources

  • Research Methodology in Behavioural Sciences (Mangal & Mangal, 2013)

Also known as

  • Historical method
  • Historical criticism
  • External criticism
  • Internal criticism
  • Source criticism
  • Higher and lower criticism

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor