Description
Participants highlight text that raises their confidence in one colour and text that lowers it in another; marks are aggregated into a heat map showing what to keep or rewrite.
A low-fidelity content test. Each participant receives a printed or digital copy of the content and two highlighters: green for words or passages that make them feel more confident, red (or yellow) for those that make them less confident or confused. After each session the researcher transfers marks onto a master copy in matching colours, so darker areas show consistent effects across participants; digital tools can tally automatically. Other reaction pairs work too, such as helpful versus unhelpful, and large samples can be split so each group marks one reaction. A variant asks participants to sort words, phrases and questions by trust or confidence. It is quick, makes the effect of wording visible to the team immediately, and pairs well with a short interview about the marks.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Information Architecture & Content
- Loss type
- Active
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Choose the content and the reactions to capture, such as more versus less confident, or helpful versus unhelpful.
- Give each participant a copy with one colour per reaction, or split a large sample so each group marks one reaction.
- Ask participants to read and highlight, then briefly explain their main marks.
- Transfer each participant's highlights onto a master copy, or tally words and phrases by reaction and participant count in a spreadsheet.
- Read the density of colours to find passages that consistently build or erode confidence.
- Rewrite negatively marked passages and retest with the intended audience.
Sources
- Strategic Content Design (Jorgensen, 2023)
- User Research (Marsh, 2022)
- User Research: A Practical Guide to Designing Better Products and Services (Marsh, 2018)
Also known as
- Highlighter testing
- Content highlighting test
- Highlighter confidence test
- Red-green highlighting content test
- Confidence highlighting
- Highlighting content
Categories
- Content
- Information Architecture & Content