Description
Analyses the depth, breadth, balance and consistency of an interface hierarchy, checking it against evidence on navigation performance and against how users group content.
Hierarchies trade depth against breadth. Research from the 1980s and 1990s found broad, shallow menus (for example 8x8 rather than 2x2x2x2x2x2) generally faster and less error-prone, provided items are well grouped and labelled, because each extra level adds a decision and a chance to go astray. Hierarchical structure analysis measures depth to each leaf, breadth at each node, balance (variation of depth), and consistency of classification principle at each level, then compares against user mental models from card sorting or tree testing. Simon's insight that near-decomposable hierarchies are easier to understand provides the theoretical basis. Today the term survives but usually means drawing a sitemap rather than analysing it.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Information Architecture & Content
- Loss type
- Vestigial
- Stage
- Definition, Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Export the full hierarchy (sitemap, menu tree, settings tree) with every node and leaf.
- Compute depth to each leaf, breadth per node, mean and maximum depth, and depth variance; flag leaves deeper than 4 levels and nodes with fewer than 3 or more than about 12 unclustered children.
- Check each level for a single, consistent classification principle (by task, object, audience or time).
- Run a tree test with 50+ participants on 8-10 key tasks to measure success and directness.
- Correlate failures with depth, breadth and classification inconsistencies.
- Propose a restructured hierarchy and re-test with a new tree test.
Sources
- Weyers, B., Bowen, J., Dix, A. & Palanque, P. (eds), The Handbook of Formal Methods in Human-Computer Interaction (2017)
- Handbook of Formal Methods in HCI
- The Inquiry Series, Ch 6 — Strange Loops, Recursive Failures & Navigation Traps
- Hofstadter, D., Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid (1979)
- Gödel Escher Bach (Hofstadter)
Also known as
- Hierarchy depth and breadth analysis
- Tree structure analysis
Categories
- Content
- Information Architecture & Content