HEART Human Reliability Assessment (with NARA and CARA)

Description

Estimate a task's human error probability by classifying it as a generic task type and multiplying the nominal error rate by weighted error-producing conditions.

HEART is a first-generation human reliability assessment that rates whole tasks rather than decomposing them as THERP does, on the premise that reliability depends on the generic nature of the task. The analyst classifies the task into one of nine generic task types, from 'totally unfamiliar, performed at speed' to 'completely familiar, well designed, highly practised', each with a nominal human error probability and 5th and 95th percentile bounds. Relevant error-producing conditions are chosen from a list of 38, each with a maximum multiplier (unfamiliarity with an important but rare situation can multiply error by 17). For each, the analyst judges the assessed proportion of affect from 0.1 to 1, computes a weighting factor and multiplies it into the nominal value. NARA replaces the generic tasks with 18 nuclear tasks and CORE-DATA values; CARA adapts it to air traffic control. Not to be confused with Google's HEART metrics framework.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Describe the task and the human failure event of concern, drawing on prior task and error analysis.
  2. Classify the task into one of the nine generic task types (or a NARA or CARA task) and take its nominal human error probability.
  3. Select the applicable error-producing conditions from the list of 38, using earlier qualitative analysis.
  4. Judge the assessed proportion of affect (0.1 to 1) for each selected condition.
  5. Compute each condition's weighting factor as ((maximum effect - 1) x proportion of affect) + 1 and multiply the nominal probability by all factors to obtain the assessed probability.
  6. Target error reduction at the conditions with the largest weighting factors and re-assess the redesigned task.

Sources

  • Handbook of Human Factors and Ergonomics (Salvendy & Karwowski, 2021)

Also known as

  • Human Error Assessment and Reduction Technique
  • NARA
  • Nuclear Action Reliability Assessment
  • CARA
  • Controller Action Reliability Assessment

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error