Groupware Walkthrough with Mechanics of Collaboration

Description

Inspect a shared-workspace prototype by walking evaluators through realistic group scenarios whose collaborative subtasks are specified with seven mechanics of collaboration.

A discount inspection method for groupware, adapting the cognitive walkthrough to teamwork. Scenarios are written from observed group work, naming the activity, group goal, users and circumstances. Tasks list what is done, not how, and are split into individual and collaborative subtasks. Collaborative subtasks are specified by the mechanics of collaboration: explicit communication, implicit communication, coordination, planning, monitoring, assistance and protection. The task model deliberately avoids strict hierarchy or order because the tightness of coupling between collaborators varies. Evaluators then step through tasks, subtasks and alternative actions in the prototype at both loose and tight coupling, recording where the workspace fails to support awareness, hand-offs or protection of others' work. Unlike Group Task Analysis, which maps a group's task flow in a participatory session, this is an expert inspection of a specific collaborative interface.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Observe real group work and write scenarios stating the activity, the group goal, the users and their circumstances.
  2. List the tasks in each scenario as what must be achieved, not how.
  3. Split tasks into individual and collaborative subtasks and specify each collaborative subtask by the mechanics it involves (explicit and implicit communication, coordination, planning, monitoring, assistance, protection).
  4. List alternative actions a group could take for each collaborative subtask.
  5. Walk two or more evaluators through the tasks, subtasks and actions in the prototype, once under loose and once under tight coupling.
  6. Record each breakdown against the mechanic it violates and consolidate a groupware usability problem list.

Sources

  • Handbook of Cognitive Task Design (Hollnagel, 2003)

Also known as

  • Groupware walkthrough
  • Mechanics of collaboration analysis
  • Group task model with mechanics of collaboration

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation