Description
Evaluates interface and conversational messages against Grice's four maxims to find where text says too much or too little, misleads, is irrelevant or is unclear.
Grice's cooperative principle holds that conversational partners expect contributions to be as informative as required and no more (Quantity), truthful and evidenced (Quality), relevant (Relation), and clear, brief and orderly (Manner). Users read interface text as cooperative communication, so violations produce misunderstanding or unintended inferences. A Gricean maxim audit reviews each message, especially errors, confirmations, warnings and chatbot responses, against each maxim, records violations, and rates severity by consequence. It is particularly valuable for conversational interfaces and AI outputs, which can be fluent yet violate Quality (unsupported claims) or Quantity (padding). Rigour comes from using two independent reviewers, explicit criteria per maxim and validation with users on high-severity items.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Collect all messages in scope: errors, warnings, confirmations, empty states, tooltips and conversational responses.
- Define operational criteria for each maxim (for example Quantity: includes cause and next step, no unrequested detail).
- Have two reviewers independently rate each message on each maxim as met, minor violation or major violation; reconcile disagreements.
- Rate severity by consequence of misunderstanding (for example 1-4 scale) and prioritise major violations with high severity.
- Rewrite flagged messages and test with 5-10 users using interpretation questions.
- Encode maxim criteria into content guidelines and review checklists.
Sources
- Gleason, J. B., The Development of Language
- Hall, E., Conversational Design (2018)
- Gopinath, V., Methods Atlas (Gricean audit)
- Development of Language (Gleason)
- Conversational Design (Hall)
- Methods Atlas — Gricean audit (Gopinath)
- The Inquiry Series, Ch 18 — Pragmatics — What Language Actually Does
Also known as
- Gricean audit
- Cooperative principle audit
- Maxim audit
Categories
- Content
- Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse