Description
A two-level coding approach moving from informant-centric first-order concepts to researcher-centric second-order themes and then aggregate theoretical dimensions.
The Gioia approach gives qualitative analysis a visible, defensible structure. First-order concepts stay close to informants' own terms and can number 50 to 100 early on. The researcher then asks what is going on theoretically and groups first-order concepts into second-order themes that use researcher language and connect to concepts in the literature. Themes are distilled into a small number of aggregate dimensions. The method assumes informants are knowledgeable agents who can explain their own actions, while the researcher's job is to see patterns informants cannot. Rigour comes from preserving the informant voice at the first level, the explicit traceability from quotes to dimensions, and the iterative movement between data and literature.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Definition
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Open code transcripts using informants' terms as much as possible, producing first-order concepts; expect 50 to 100 initially and consolidate duplicates to roughly 20 to 40.
- Look for similarities and differences among first-order concepts and group them into second-order themes, labelled in researcher language and linked to existing constructs where relevant.
- Ask of each theme whether it suggests a concept that explains the phenomenon, and consult the literature to see whether it is known or novel.
- Distil second-order themes into 2 to 5 aggregate theoretical dimensions.
- Assemble the data structure diagram, and build a supporting table with 2 to 4 representative quotes per first-order concept.
- Check coding with a second researcher acting as devil's advocate on 20% to 30% of data, and revise until disagreements are resolved.
Sources
- Gioia (Administrative Science Quarterly) via Sage Handbook
- Rocking Qualitative Social Science
- The Inquiry Series, Ch 28 — The Gioia Methodology — Identity-First Systematic Analysis
Also known as
- First-order and second-order coding
- Gioia coding
- Informant-centric to theory-centric coding
Categories
- User Research
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis