Description
Classifies errors by the cognitive level at which they occur, separating skill-based slips and lapses from rule-based and knowledge-based mistakes, each with distinct remedies.
GEMS integrates Rasmussen's skill-rule-knowledge framework with Reason's slips, lapses and mistakes. At the skill-based level, errors come from attentional failures (slips, such as capture errors) and memory failures (lapses). When a problem is detected, people move to the rule-based level, where they misapply good rules or apply bad ones. When no rule fits, they enter knowledge-based reasoning, prone to bounded rationality, confirmation bias and incomplete mental models. GEMS gives an explicit diagnostic flow: was the user monitoring, problem-solving or reasoning from first principles when the error occurred? The rigour comes from assigning each observed error to a mechanism, which then dictates the fix: forcing functions for slips, better feedback for lapses, clearer rules and signs for rule-based mistakes, and better representations for knowledge-based ones.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Human Factors & Error
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Evaluation, Post-launch
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Collect error incidents from usability sessions, support tickets, logs or critical incident interviews, with enough context to reconstruct intention.
- For each incident, establish whether the intention was correct (execution failure) or incorrect (planning failure).
- Classify execution failures as slips (attention: capture, description, mode errors) or lapses (memory: omissions, place-losing).
- Classify planning failures as rule-based (misapplied good rule, applied bad rule, strong-but-wrong rule) or knowledge-based (incomplete model, confirmation bias, overconfidence).
- Check classification reliability with a second coder and compute Cohen's kappa, targeting at least 0.6.
- Map each error class to its remedy family and prioritise redesigns by frequency times severity.
Sources
- Reason, Human Error (1990)
- Rasmussen, Information Processing and Human-Machine Interaction (1986)
Also known as
- GEMS
- Reason's GEMS
Categories
- Accessibility
- Human Factors & Error