Generative Design Loop

Description

A tight cycle of group ideation, sketching and critiquing grounded in research models, with idea generation (go mode) kept strictly apart from judgement (stop mode).

Generative design treats ideation, sketching, critiquing and refining as one fast loop rather than separate phases. The team first immerses itself in posted research models, personas and requirements, then holds ideation sessions each focused on one model. Ideas are pushed with named techniques: reframing, abstraction, the magic wand (assume any technology is possible, then work back), incubation, borrowing patterns from other domains and systematically traversing the dimensions of the problem space (for example mass, volume and visibility). Everything is talked through as user scenarios and sketched or mocked up physically. Mason's distinction between go-mode and stop-mode thinking is the discipline: critique begins only when ideas run dry, and then checks goals, fit with the work ecology, usability, emotional impact and meaningfulness, ideally with a broad cross-section of people including users. The loop is repeated many times.

Attributes

Loss type
Active
Stage
Design
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Post the research models, personas and requirements on the walls and walk the team through them.
  2. Run ideation sessions of one model each, in go mode only: no evaluation, every idea sketched or noted.
  3. Apply stimulus techniques deliberately: reframe, abstract, use the magic wand, borrow cross-domain patterns, and traverse each dimension of the problem space.
  4. Talk in user scenarios and sketch everything; build rough physical mock-ups where form matters.
  5. Switch to stop mode only when ideas run dry, critiquing sketches for goals, ecology fit, usability, emotional impact and meaningfulness.
  6. Invite a wide cross-section of people, including users, to argue over the sketches while the designers listen.
  7. Refine the surviving ideas and loop again, many times, before committing to a prototype.

Sources

  • The UX Book (Hartson & Pyla, 2019)
  • Prototyping for Designers (McElroy, 2016)

Also known as

  • Generative design
  • Ideation-sketching-critiquing
  • Go-mode and stop-mode thinking
  • Magic wand ideation
  • Problem-space dimension traversal
  • Generative design loop: ideation, sketching and critiquing with go and stop modes

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice