General Morphological Analysis

Description

Breaks a problem into dimensions with discrete options, then uses cross-consistency assessment to reduce the full configuration space to viable solutions.

Zwicky, an astrophysicist, used morphological analysis to explore all possible configurations of jet engines and astronomical objects. The problem is decomposed into parameters, each with a range of values, forming a morphological field whose cells represent all combinations, often millions. Ritchey's cross-consistency assessment (CCA) asks pairwise whether value combinations are compatible, eliminating inconsistent configurations and leaving a manageable solution space. This prevents premature fixation on familiar concepts, ensures systematic coverage of alternatives, and is valuable in design ideation, service concepts and policy scenarios.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Define the problem and identify 4-8 key parameters (dimensions) of possible solutions.
  2. For each parameter, list mutually exclusive values (typically 3-7).
  3. Conduct cross-consistency assessment for every pair of values across parameters (consistent, inconsistent, conditionally consistent).
  4. Use software or scripts to generate the reduced set of internally consistent configurations.
  5. Explore the solution space: cluster configurations, identify novel combinations and evaluate them.
  6. Select configurations for prototyping or scenario development.

Sources

  • Zwicky, Discovery, Invention, Research through the Morphological Approach (1969)
  • Ritchey, Wicked Problems, Social Messes: Decision Support Modelling with Morphological Analysis (2011)
  • Ritchey, Problem structuring using computer-aided morphological analysis (2006), Journal of the Operational Research Society

Also known as

  • Zwicky box
  • Morphological box
  • GMA
  • Morphological field analysis

Categories

  • Design
  • Participatory, Design & Futures