Description
Time how fast people classify stimuli by one attribute when a second attribute is constant, correlated or varied independently, to learn whether the two are perceived as fused or separable.
Some pairs of attributes are processed as a whole, such as the hue and brightness of one colour patch, while others can be attended separately, such as the colour and shape of separate objects. Garner's test asks people to classify stimuli as fast as possible by one designated attribute in three conditions: a control set where only that attribute varies, a correlated set where the second attribute varies with it, and an orthogonal set where the second attribute varies independently. Faster classification in the correlated set is a redundancy gain; slower classification in the orthogonal set is interference. Both, together with similarity judgements that follow a Euclidean rather than city-block metric, mark the pair as integral; their absence marks it as separable. The result tells designers whether two variables encoded in one mark can be read independently.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Design
- Data
- Quantitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Choose the two attributes to test, for example colour lightness and size of a chart marker, with two clearly discriminable levels of each.
- Build three stimulus sets: control (only the relevant attribute varies), correlated (the second attribute varies with it) and orthogonal (the second attribute varies independently).
- Instruct participants to classify each stimulus by the relevant attribute as fast and accurately as possible, by keypress or card sorting, and counterbalance set order.
- Record response times and errors for each set, after practice trials, and repeat with the other attribute as the relevant one.
- Compute redundancy gain (control minus correlated) and interference (orthogonal minus control) with confidence intervals.
- Classify the pair as integral if both effects appear, and optionally confirm with similarity ratings tested for a Euclidean versus city-block metric.
Sources
- Attention and Effort (Kahneman, 1973)
Also known as
- Garner speeded classification
- Garner interference paradigm
- Filtering and redundancy tasks
- Integrality test
- Card-sorting speeded classification
Categories
- User Research
- Cognitive Psychology & Perception