GameFlow Evaluation

Description

Evaluating enjoyment by checking a game against eight flow-based elements: concentration, challenge, player skills, control, clear goals, feedback, immersion and social interaction.

GameFlow translates Csikszentmihalyi's elements of flow into eight criteria for enjoyable games. Concentration: the game provides stimuli worth attending to. Challenge: difficulty matches skill and offers levels. Player skills: players can start without a manual and learning is part of the fun. Control: players feel in control of characters and of the interface and devices. Clear goals: overriding and intermediate goals are clear at the right time. Feedback: progress and actions get timely feedback. Immersion: players become less aware of their surroundings. Social interaction: the game supports competition, cooperation and chat. Each element comes with detailed criteria, so the model can be used as an expert review checklist or turned into statements for a post-play questionnaire. Chapter 8 does both: the authors and an industry expert analysed how freemium and advertising business models interrupt each element, then converted the criteria into a questionnaire that 15 players completed after short sessions with three mobile games, framed by semi-structured interviews. For UX, the model offers a structured vocabulary for enjoyment and for diagnosing what breaks it, such as ads or paywalls.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Select the GameFlow elements and criteria relevant to the product and context of use.
  2. For an expert review, play the product and judge each criterion, noting where and why it is met or broken.
  3. For player evaluation, convert criteria into short agreement statements for a post-play questionnaire.
  4. Have participants play for a fixed period, then complete the questionnaire.
  5. Use semi-structured interviews before and after play to explain the ratings.
  6. Summarise results by element and link breakdowns to specific design features.

Sources

  • Garcia-Ruiz, M. (ed.), Games User Research: A Case Study Approach (2016)

Also known as

  • GameFlow model
  • Sweetser and Wyeth GameFlow criteria
  • GameFlow questionnaire

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation