Game Approachability Principles (GAP)

Description

Twenty-seven heuristics for checking how well a game teaches new and casual players to play, covering demonstration, practice, feedback, self-efficacy and knowledge transfer.

GAP complements the PLAY heuristics by focusing on approachability: how a game helps people who lack gaming conventions, or have little time, to get into it. The authors argue that as games grew more complex and audiences broadened, casual players became more likely to quit when a game felt hard and less likely to seek help from guides or forums, so learning support became critical. The 27 heuristics are grouped into categories such as demonstration and practice, demonstration of actions with feedback, self-efficacy and knowledge transfer. Examples include 'the game allows the player to practise', 'the player knows what actions they are able to perform', 'after the initial training period the player feels they have learned enough to play' and 'the game is similar to other games of a genre'. GAP is applied in the same inductive or deductive ways as PLAY, recording adherences, violations and enhancements. For UX teams outside games, GAP is a ready-made checklist for onboarding and learnability, grounded in ideas about modelling, practice and self-efficacy.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Define the target novice or casual player and the skills the first session must teach.
  2. Play through the first-time experience as that player would.
  3. Check each GAP heuristic and record adherences, violations and enhancement ideas.
  4. Pay particular attention to whether actions are demonstrated, practised with feedback and reinforced.
  5. Compare findings across evaluators and prioritise violations that block early progress.
  6. Validate key issues with a small first-time playtest.

Sources

  • Drachen, A., Mirza-Babaei, P. & Nacke, L. (eds), Games User Research (2018)

Also known as

  • GAP
  • GAP heuristics
  • Game approachability heuristics

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation