Functionalism and Multiple Realisability in UI Design

Description

Defines interface elements by their functional role, the inputs, outputs and relations they support, so equivalent functions can be realised differently across platforms and modalities.

Functionalist philosophy of mind: mental states are defined by their functional role (causal relations to inputs, outputs, and other mental states), not by their physical substrate. Multiple realizability: the same functional state can be realized by different physical implementations. Applied to UX: the same user cognitive state (confusion, engagement, flow) can be produced by many different interface implementations — and any interface producing the right functional role produces the right experience.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify the target cognitive/emotional state (e.g., flow, trust, engagement). Apply functional role analysis: what must be true of a design to produce this state?
  2. (1) What inputs (interface properties) must be present?
  3. (2) What other states must it connect to (preconditions, consequences)?
  4. (3) What outputs (user behaviors) should it produce? Any design satisfying all three criteria should work — test multiple realizations.

Sources

  • Mind Design II — MIT Press (Haugeland, ed.)
  • Putnam, Psychological predicates (1967)
  • Fodor, The Language of Thought (1975)

Also known as

  • Functional-role analysis of UI components
  • Multiple realisability analysis

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Systems & Complexity