Description
Predict the time of a speeded response by chaining fixed functional operations (perceive, encode, attend, comprehend, task set-up, intend, decode, move) and summing stipulated operator times.
For speeded, practised, low-error tasks, Newell describes an abstract analysis at a finer grain than GOMS. The analyst does not write a running model but decomposes the response into a fixed order of functions: Perceive, Encode, Attend, Comprehend, Task set-up, Intend, Decode, Move. For each, they decide whether it is needed and how many operators or productions it takes, apply stipulated constants (production about 20 ms, minimal operator about 60 ms, perception about 40 ms, simple motor act about 60 ms) and sum. This gives about 220 ms for simple reaction and about 380 ms for two-choice reaction. For stimulus-response compatibility, the mapping is written as an algorithm of operators from stimulus to response: John's model fitted 27 compatibility situations with about 12% average error and predicted recall of command abbreviations, such as typing 'dlt' for 'delete' (about 2,573 ms predicted against 2,400 ms observed).
Attributes
- Discipline
- Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling
- Loss type
- Extinct
- Stage
- Design
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Check the task fits the immediate-response paradigm: speeded, prepared person, controlled setting, simple practised stimulus-response rule.
- Lay out the functions in fixed order (Perceive, Encode, Attend, Comprehend, Task set-up, Intend, Decode, Move) and mark which are needed.
- For mapping tasks such as abbreviations or key assignments, write the mapping algorithm as a chain of operators from stimulus to response.
- Assign stipulated constants (for example production 20 ms, minimal operator 60 ms, perception 40 ms, motor act 60 ms) to each operator.
- Sum to predict response time for each design alternative or mapping rule.
- Compare predictions with observed mean times from a small test and refine the algorithm if errors exceed about 15%.
Sources
- Unified Theories of Cognition (Newell, 1990)
Also known as
- Functional-operation response-time accounting (P-E-A-C-T-I-D-M)
- SRC algorithm analysis
- Stimulus-response compatibility time prediction
- John-Rosenbloom-Newell SRC model
- Immediate-response functional analysis
Categories
- User Research
- Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling