Function Allocation (Fitts List / MABA-MABA)

Description

Systematically decides which functions should be performed by people and which by machines, based on comparative strengths and the needs of the joint system.

The original Fitts list compared human and machine capabilities (humans better at improvisation and judgement; machines at speed, precision and repetition) to allocate functions. Later work criticised static allocation and proposed dynamic or adaptive allocation and the joint cognitive system perspective, in which the question is how people and automation coordinate rather than who does what. A rigorous allocation analysis lists system functions, evaluates candidate allocations against criteria (performance, workload, situation awareness, skill retention, accountability), and checks for leftover-task problems where people are given only what automation cannot do. With AI assistants this extinct method is suddenly central: every agentic feature is an allocation decision usually made by engineering convenience.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. List the system's functions independently of who or what performs them, from a goal-means or task analysis.
  2. For each function, identify candidate allocations: human, machine, shared, or adaptive.
  3. Evaluate candidates against explicit criteria: accuracy, speed, workload, situation awareness, skill decay, accountability, user values.
  4. Check the residual human role for coherence, avoiding 'leftover' allocations that leave people monitoring without context.
  5. Define handover and takeover protocols, including how humans are brought back into the loop.
  6. Test the allocation with simulation or Wizard of Oz under normal and degraded automation conditions.

Sources

  • Fitts (ed.), Human Engineering for an Effective Air-Navigation and Traffic-Control System (1951)
  • Dekker & Woods, MABA-MABA or Abracadabra? Progress on human-automation co-ordination (2002), Cognition, Technology & Work
  • Hollnagel & Woods, Joint Cognitive Systems (2005)

Also known as

  • Fitts list
  • MABA-MABA
  • Men are better at, machines are better at
  • Allocation of function

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error