Description
A decision aid for how far to prestructure qualitative instruments before fieldwork, weighing study purpose, number of cases and familiarity with the setting.
Qualitative researchers disagree about how much to prepare instruments in advance. Miles and Huberman set out the arguments for little prior instrumentation, for a lot, and for 'it depends', and turn them into explicit factors. Loose designs suit studies needing rich context, locally grounded concepts, exploration, single complex cases and minimal researcher influence. Tight designs suit predefined concepts, confirmatory or evaluative aims, multiple cases where comparability matters, generalisation and links to surveys. The two stances favour different kinds of validity, so the choice is a design decision, not a matter of taste; the authors place themselves off centre, toward the structured end. The decision can differ by phase: an exploratory first wave can precede a tighter confirmatory one. Multi-case work typically uses a common semi-structured guide whose wording and order fieldworkers may adapt, revised between visits.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Research Design & Rigor
- Loss type
- Latent
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Characterise the study: exploratory or confirmatory, single or multiple case, basic or applied, and how familiar the team is with the setting.
- Mark which phases of the study are exploratory and which confirmatory.
- Score the loose-versus-tight factors (need for local meaning, comparability across cases, predefined concepts, generalisation, links to quantitative data) and choose a position for each phase.
- Build only the instruments needed at the outset; defer others until early data show what matters.
- For multiple cases, write a common semi-structured guide whose wording and order fieldworkers may adapt.
- Record the chosen stance and its rationale in the plan, and revise instruments between visits.
Sources
- Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)
Also known as
- Prestructuring decision
- Loose versus tight design
Categories
- Research Operations
- Research Design & Rigor