Description
Six heuristics for inspecting how a free-to-play game handles in-app purchases, covering fair progression, transparency, value, protection of minors, earnable hard currency and fairness between payers and non-payers.
In free-to-play games the revenue model is part of the game design and purchases happen during play, so monetisation affects the player experience directly. The authors propose a module of six heuristics to add to a playability evaluation: FP1 progression is possible without in-app purchases (no hard paywall); FP2 purchases and transactions are clearly informed, with visible prices and separate confirmation; FP3 purchases provide meaningful value rather than inferior or obsolete content; FP4 purchases can be made inaccessible for minors; FP5 hard currency can be earned through gameplay in limited amounts, so non-payers experience its benefits; FP6 gameplay is fair for paying and non-paying players, avoiding pay-to-win. They are drawn from developer and player interviews, evaluation experiments and game analyses, and focus on fair play, transparency and ethics. The authors present them as an initial list that had not been thoroughly validated. For UX researchers, the set is a compact checklist for reviewing any freemium or in-app purchase design for practices that frustrate users or create reputational risk, and sits alongside dark-pattern reviews.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Usability & Evaluation
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Add the six F2P heuristics to the playability heuristics used for the evaluation.
- Play the game as a non-paying player through early and mid progression.
- Inspect every purchase prompt, price display, confirmation and currency flow.
- Check parental controls and how purchases can be restricted for minors.
- In competitive modes, compare what paying players can buy against what affects winning.
- Record violations with evidence, rate severity and discuss ethical and reputational risk with the team.
Sources
- Drachen, A., Mirza-Babaei, P. & Nacke, L. (eds), Games User Research (2018)
Also known as
- F2P heuristics
- FP1-FP6 heuristics
- Monetisation playability heuristics
Categories
- User Research
- Usability & Evaluation