Free Listing and Cultural Salience Analysis

Description

Asks people to list all items in a domain, then uses frequency and order of mention to identify the domain's boundaries and most salient items.

Free listing is a simple, powerful elicitation: 'list all the ways you pay bills' or 'all the things you worry about when travelling with children'. Items mentioned often and early are culturally salient. Smith's S combines frequency and rank; Sutrop's index is a related measure. Saturation in free lists can be checked as new respondents add few new items. Free lists define the domain for later card sorts, pile sorts and surveys, ensuring the item set reflects users' categories rather than designers'. With 20-30 respondents per group, cross-group comparisons reveal different mental landscapes.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Data
Mixed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Choose a clear domain prompt and pilot it for interpretability.
  2. Ask each respondent to list as many items as they can, with neutral prompts for more (e.g. 'what else?').
  3. Clean and standardise items carefully, preserving respondents' language where possible.
  4. Compute frequency, mean rank and Smith's salience index for each item.
  5. Plot salience distributions and identify the domain core and periphery; check saturation.
  6. Use salient items to build card sorts, survey options, navigation labels or intents.

Sources

  • Weller & Romney, Systematic Data Collection (1988)
  • Smith, Using ANTHOPAC 3.5 and a spreadsheet to compute a free-list salience index (1993), Cultural Anthropology Methods
  • Bernard, Research Methods in Anthropology (6th ed., 2017)

Also known as

  • Free listing
  • Free list analysis
  • Smith's salience index
  • Sutrop's index

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation