Five-Layer Model of Game Evaluation

Description

A layered lens that links appeal, understanding, usability, player experience and monetisation, used to choose research methods and explain how low-level problems surface as revenue problems.

The five-layer model was derived from Player Research's work on free-to-play games, where developers blamed poor revenue on economy balancing when the real cause was often in the game itself. From the bottom up the layers are appeal (does the game attract players to download it), understanding (do players know the rules and what is available), usability (can they do what the designer intends), player experience (do they enjoy it) and monetisation (do they pay). Each layer depends on those beneath it, so a problem seen at the top may originate far lower down. Premium games without in-app purchases use a four-layer version without monetisation. The studio maps each research method onto the layers it 'polishes' (high, medium or low), from concept tests and competitor analysis through usability and large-scale playtests to engagement diaries and analytics-driven playtests, producing a matrix that shows which methods are needed at which stage. For UX teams the model is a communication and planning tool: it helps stakeholders see that a conversion or retention problem may be an understanding problem and that no single method covers every layer.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. List the layers that apply to the product (drop monetisation for paid products).
  2. For each planned or possible research method, rate how strongly it informs each layer.
  3. Map methods onto development phases to build a layer-by-phase coverage matrix.
  4. When a top-layer metric is poor, trace candidate causes down through the layers.
  5. Choose the methods that cover the layers where causes are most likely.
  6. Use the matrix in conversations with the team to show gaps in research coverage.

Sources

  • Drachen, A., Mirza-Babaei, P. & Nacke, L. (eds), Games User Research (2018)

Also known as

  • Player Research five-layer model
  • Four-layer model (premium games)
  • Appeal-Understanding-Usability-Experience-Monetisation model

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Product Analytics & Strategy