Figure-Ground Audit

Description

Study what an interface, a dataset or a research plan leaves out as deliberately as what it shows, because the absences have a shape of their own.

Hofstadter uses Escher's tessellations, where birds and fish define each other's outlines, to make a logical point: sometimes the set of things a system does not produce is as structured and informative as the set it does. In UX the 'figure' is what gets attention: the features on screen, the events in the analytics, the users who answered the survey. The 'ground' is everything else: options that were removed, actions that are not tracked, people who never signed up or churned before being asked. A figure-ground audit lists that ground explicitly and asks what shape it has. Missing states in an interface, untracked events in an analytics plan and missing groups in a sample are not random; they follow the assumptions of whoever drew the figure, and they often explain blind spots in findings.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Choose the figure to audit: a screen or flow, an analytics tracking plan, a survey sample or a set of research findings.
  2. List what the figure contains in one column.
  3. In a second column list what could reasonably be there and is not: states, options, events, people, questions. Use competitors, earlier versions, support logs and domain experts to fill it.
  4. Group the absences and look for a pattern in who or what is consistently left out.
  5. For each group, decide whether the absence is deliberate and justified, or a blind spot.
  6. Turn blind spots into design changes, extra tracking, recruitment targets or research questions.

Sources

  • Hofstadter, D., Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid (1979)

Also known as

  • Negative space audit
  • Absence audit

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor