Description
Design exercises that make users expert: sub-skill drills reaching 95 percent reliability within three sessions, and high-volume exposure to varied expert examples with fast feedback.
Sierra argues that products succeed when users become good at what the product helps them do, and that expertise comes from two designable things. Deliberate practice: list skills on three boards (Can't do, Can do with effort, Mastered), give beginners a minimum viable starter set, then drill one fine-grained sub-skill at a time with a pass/fail exercise that should reach 95 percent reliability within one to three 45-90 minute sessions. If it does not, the exercise is redesigned by splitting the sub-skill finer or lowering the criteria. Perceptual exposure: present many short, high-quality expert examples that differ on the surface but share an invariant, ask learners to classify or choose, and give prompt feedback, letting the pattern be learned implicitly. Kellman and Kaiser's non-pilots outperformed pilots on instrument reading after 432 such trials. Both are tested by comparing performance before and after, not by satisfaction.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Design & Product Practice
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Design, Post-launch
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- List the skills the product's users need as cards on three boards: Can't do, With effort, Mastered; mark a minimum viable starter set for beginners.
- Pick one fine-grained sub-skill users cannot yet do reliably and write a pass/fail exercise with explicit criteria.
- Run one to three sessions of 45-90 minutes, close together; the target is 95 percent reliability.
- If the target is missed, split the sub-skill finer (fewer steps, one hand, one case) or lower the criteria (half speed) and retry.
- For perceptual judgements, collect dozens to hundreds of short expert examples that vary on the surface but share the target pattern; avoid showing bad examples early.
- Present them in a compressed period with a classify-or-choose task and feedback per trial or per block (for example blocks of 24).
- Evaluate by comparing learners' outputs before and after; if gains are small, add more and more varied examples or shorten the feedback gap.
- Keep few skills on the With-effort board and schedule de-automation drills for plateaued skills.
Sources
- Badass: Making Users Awesome (Sierra, 2015)
Also known as
- Deliberate Practice Exercise Design (95 percent in three sessions)
- Perceptual Exposure Training Design
- Half-a-skill beats half-assed skills
- Three-board skill model
- Can't do / With effort / Mastered boards
- Minimum viable skill set
- Perceptual learning exercises
- High-quantity high-quality exposure
- Guess-with-feedback training
Categories
- Design
- Design & Product Practice