Expert and Key Informant Interviewing

Description

Specialised interviewing of domain experts and organisational insiders that bypasses automated knowledge through incidents, exceptions and demonstration.

Experts have automated much of their skill, so asking 'how do you do X' produces textbook rationalisations rather than real process. Professional identity also discourages admitting uncertainty or workarounds. Key informant interviewing addresses this with tactics drawn from anthropology, elite interviewing and knowledge elicitation. The researcher prepares thoroughly to converse as a peer, uses critical incidents to anchor accounts in real difficult cases, asks about exceptions rather than rules, and where possible has the expert perform and narrate a task. Key informants, insiders with privileged views of an organisation or community, are also used to map structure, politics and context quickly, with their partiality acknowledged and triangulated.

Attributes

Loss type
Active
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Demonstrate competence first: Read relevant material before the interview. Show the expert you know enough to have a conversation rather than a tutorial. This changes the dynamic from teacher→student to peer→peer.
  2. Use critical incident technique: "Tell me about a time when [the task/problem] was particularly difficult." Specific incidents bypass automatisation and surface actual process.
  3. Ask about exceptions, not rules: "When does the standard approach not work?" "What do you do differently in unusual cases?" Exceptions reveal the underlying structure that the rules describe imperfectly.
  4. Use the think-aloud while doing approach: Ask the expert to perform a task while narrating their thinking. Concurrent verbalization (during the task) is more accurate than retrospective account (after the task).

Sources

  • The Science and Art of Interviewing (Blee)
  • Qualitative Interviewing
  • Handbook of Cognitive Task Design (Hollnagel)
  • Elite and Specialized Interviewing (Dexter)
  • Working Minds (Crandall, Klein & Hoffman)
  • Gratton, C. & Jones, I., Research Methods for Sports Studies (2010)

Also known as

  • Key informant interview
  • Elite interviewing
  • Subject matter expert interview

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation