Description
Reveals the taken-for-granted methods people use to produce order by observing sense-making and, ethically, introducing small breaches that make tacit expectations visible.
Ethnomethodology (Garfinkel, 1967) studies how people practically produce and sustain the sense of orderly social life in everyday interaction. Its central insight: the rules and methods people use to make sense of their social world are so taken-for-granted that they are invisible — until they are broken. Garfinkel's 'breaching experiments' deliberately violated ordinary conversational and social rules to expose the tacit normative structure that ordinarily makes interaction seamless. Applied to UX: breaching reveals the implicit interaction contracts users bring to interfaces — contracts that, when violated, produce confusion, frustration, or the specific error type known as 'violation of expectation.'
Attributes
- Discipline
- Field & Ethnographic
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Discovery
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Naturalistic observation of sense-making: Observe how people handle moments of ambiguity, confusion, or breakdown in digital interactions. Focus on the repair work they do to restore sense — what assumptions do they invoke?
- Indexicality analysis: Identify all the things that are left unsaid, pointed to, or taken for granted in a user's verbal account of their experience. These are the tacit background expectations that must be in place for interaction to work.
- Breaching experiment design (applied): Deliberately introduce a small, controlled violation of a design convention — a non-standard icon placement, an unexpected response, a missing affordance. Observe the recovery work users do. What assumptions are they repairing from?
- Documentary method: Analyse how users interpret ambiguous interface elements by treating their interpretation as 'documents of a pattern.' What underlying pattern are they reading the element against?
- Analysis: Code repair sequences for: (a) what rule was assumed, (b) how the violation was detected, (c) what repair strategy was used, (d) whether repair succeeded or failed.
Sources
- Studies in Ethnomethodology (Garfinkel)
- Sage Research Methods — Understanding Qualitative Research and Ethnomethodology (ten Have)
- Handbook of Ethnography
- Plans and Situated Actions (Suchman)
Also known as
- Garfinkel breaching experiments
- Ethnomethodological study
- Breaching
Categories
- User Research
- Field & Ethnographic