Description
Elicits the decision criteria people actually use from interviews, builds them into explicit decision trees, and tests their predictive accuracy on a new sample.
Gladwin studied why farmers chose particular crops or practices. She elicited decision criteria from informants, structured them as hierarchical decision trees with elimination by aspects and constraints, and then tested the trees on a separate sample of decision-makers, typically achieving 85-95% prediction accuracy. Errors were examined to refine the model. The method combines qualitative elicitation with quantitative validation, producing an explicit, testable model of real decision processes rather than assumed rational choice. For UX, it suits choices like which plan to buy, whether to switch providers, or whether to use a feature, producing models that can guide design and messaging.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Field & Ethnographic
- Loss type
- Extinct
- Stage
- Discovery
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Choose a specific, recurrent decision (e.g. choosing a mobile money provider) and a sample of decision-makers.
- Interview 20-30 informants about recent decisions, eliciting criteria, constraints and alternatives in their own terms.
- Build a composite decision tree with ordered criteria, aspects and constraints.
- Test the model on a new sample of 20-60 decision-makers by predicting their actual choices.
- Analyse errors, revise the model and re-test where feasible.
- Translate the model into design: support key criteria, remove constraints, and match messaging to decision order.
Sources
- Gladwin, Ethnographic Decision Tree Modeling (1989), Sage Qualitative Research Methods Series 19
- Bernard, Research Methods in Anthropology (6th ed., 2017)
Also known as
- Ethnographic decision tree modelling
- EDM
- Hierarchical decision models
Categories
- User Research
- Field & Ethnographic