Description
Interview people as accountable reasoners: ask what shared concepts mean, respectfully challenge their answers and test whether their reasons hold.
Most qualitative interviewing treats the participant as a holder of experiences or opinions to be recorded without challenge. Epistemic interviewing positions the interviewee as someone giving reasons who can be held to them. The interviewer asks about concepts and norms rather than lived experience (what counts as fair, as trustworthy, as a good tool), offers counter-cases, points out tensions and asks for justification. The interviewer may talk as much as the interviewee, and biography is of little interest. The aim is articulated and tested justifications, and the conversation may well end unresolved; knowledge emerges from the dialogue itself, in the spirit of phronetic social science. Rigour rests on respectful, transparent challenge and on reporting the exchange, not only the participant's final position. It can feel adversarial and is unsuitable for sensitive personal topics.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Interviewing & Elicitation
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Strategy, Definition
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Choose a concept or norm of shared concern, such as fairness, privacy or quality, relevant to the decision at hand.
- Ask the interviewee to state what it is or how it should be applied in their work.
- Offer counter-cases or edge cases that test the stated view.
- Ask for reasons and examine with them whether those reasons hold or conflict.
- Keep the tone respectful, make the challenging stance explicit up front, and let the exchange end unresolved if necessary.
- Analyse transcripts for the justifications offered, how they shifted under challenge and which held.
Sources
- The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research (Denzin & Lincoln, 2017)
Also known as
- Socratic interviewing
- Epistemic interview
- Confrontational interviewing
Categories
- User Research
- Interviewing & Elicitation