Description
Classify observed actions as pragmatic (advancing the goal) or epistemic (changing the world to ease thinking), and inventory how people arrange space to simplify choice, perception and computation.
Kirsh and Maglio distinguished pragmatic actions, which move a person towards a physical goal, from epistemic actions, which change the world mainly to make their own information processing easier, faster or more reliable. Expert Tetris players physically rotate falling pieces because screen rotation beats mental rotation; Scrabble players shuffle tiles to prompt word recall. Kirsh's 'intelligent use of space' adds that people arrange workspaces to simplify choice, perception or internal computation, for example laying out a dismantled part's pieces in order or separating heavy and fragile groceries. Clark argues such actions are far more common than planning models assume, showing brain and world working as one system. Maglio, Wenger and Copeland quantified the benefit by comparing processing capacity (hazard function of response time) with and without the information an extra action provides against its time cost; gains grew with memory load and outweighed costs.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Discovery, Evaluation
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Observe the task as actually performed in its real setting, recording video and interaction logs rather than reconstructing an idealised procedure.
- List actions that do not advance the goal directly but reveal information, prompt memory, reduce options or reduce later computation.
- Classify each action as pragmatic or epistemic, and each spatial arrangement as simplifying choice, perception or internal computation.
- Where quantification matters, time the cost of each extra action per participant and compare response-time hazard functions with and without the information it yields, across memory-load levels.
- Explain performance as a joint person-plus-environment system and identify which epistemic actions the interface supports, blocks or forces.
- Turn findings into design: make cheap the actions people already use to think, and avoid 'tidying' away arrangements that carry information.
Sources
- Being There (Clark, 1997)
- Supersizing the Mind (Clark, 2008)
Also known as
- Epistemic action and workspace-arrangement analysis
- Epistemic versus pragmatic action
- Kirsh and Maglio epistemic action
- Intelligent use of space
- Kirsh's three uses of space
- Epistemic action in Tetris, with hazard-function measurement of its benefit
Categories
- User Research
- Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling